How to prepare for an academic integrity hearing about AI
A hearing is a structured conversation with rules. Knowing those rules, and
arriving organised, makes a real difference to how it goes.
Last reviewed 12 November 2026
Names differ — academic integrity meeting, misconduct panel, honor council — but the shape is
similar almost everywhere. Someone presents the concern, you respond, the decision-maker asks
questions, and a finding is made against a stated standard of proof. This page applies whether
you intend to contest the allegation or to accept part of it.
Before the hearing
Get the paperwork
The written allegation: which work, which rule, and what exactly you are said to have
done.
All the evidence that will be relied on, including any detector report in full, not a
screenshot of a percentage.
The procedure document: who decides, what standard of proof applies, the possible
outcomes, and how appeals work.
Ask for these in writing and note when you asked. If you are refused something, ask which
part of the procedure allows that.
Find out who can come with you
Most institutions allow a supporter: a students' union adviser, a member of staff, a friend,
or in some places a lawyer. Their role may be limited to advising you quietly. Check the rules,
and bring someone if you can. A second pair of ears is valuable.
Build a one-page timeline
List the dates: when the work was set, when you started, each drafting session, when you
submitted. Attach evidence to each line where you have it. A panel that can follow your process
on a single page is a panel that is not guessing. Our guide on
showing you wrote something yourself covers what to
collect.
Prepare a short statement
Two or three minutes, written out. Say what you did, address the specific evidence, and state
what outcome you think is right. Practise it aloud once.
If the evidence is a detector score
Ask which tool and version was used, what the full report says, and what the vendor says
about its error rate and intended use.
Ask whether anything other than the score supports the allegation.
Be on time, be polite, and answer the question that was asked.
Expect to be asked about the content of your work: why you structured it that way, what a
term means, where a source came from. Reread your own submission the night before.
If you do not know or do not remember, say so. Guessing looks worse than a gap.
Take notes, or ask your supporter to. Ask whether the hearing is being recorded and
whether you will get a copy.
If something new is produced that you have not seen, ask for time to read it.
Stay with the facts. Attacking the instructor's motives or the
institution rarely helps. A calm account supported by documents is the most persuasive thing
you can bring.
After the hearing
Ask when and how you will receive the decision, and that it be in writing with
reasons.